| Top 40 Hits of September 1958 |
| 1 |
Connie Francis | Stupid Cupid / Carolina Moon |
| 2 |
Kalin Twins | When |
| 3 |
Dean Martin | Volare (Nel Blu Dipinto Di Blu) |
| 4 |
Dean Martin | Return To Me |
| 5 |
Ricky Nelson | Poor Little Fool |
| 6 |
Peggy Lee | Fever |
| 7 |
Charlie Drake | Splish Splash |
| 8 |
Everly Brothers | All I Have To Do Is Dream / Claudette |
| 9 |
Bernard Bresslaw | Mad Passionate Love |
| 10 |
Everly Brothers | Bird Dog |
| 11 |
Marty Wilde | Endless Sleep |
| 12 |
Perez 'Prez' Prado & His Orchestra | Patricia |
| 13 |
Domenico Modugno | Volare (Nel Blu Dipinto Di Blu) |
| 14 |
Max Bygraves | Tulips From Amsterdam / You Need Hands |
| 15 |
Coasters | Yakety Yak |
| 16 |
Tony Brent | Girl Of My Dreams |
| 17 |
Joe 'Mr Piano' Henderson | Trudie |
| 18 |
Poni-Tails | Born Too Late |
| 19 |
Pat Boone | If Dreams Came True |
| 20 |
Cliff Richard | Move It |
| 21 |
Elvis Presley | Hard Headed Woman |
| 22 |
Duane Eddy | Rebel Rouser |
| 23 |
Perry Como | Moon Talk |
| 24 |
Harry Belafonte | Little Bernadette |
| 25 |
Johnny Mathis | A Certain Smile |
| 26 |
Elvis Presley | King Creole |
| 27 |
Buddy Holly | Rave On |
| 28 |
Connie Francis | Who's Sorry Now |
| 29 |
Bobby Darin | Splish Splash |
| 30 |
Buddy Holly | Early In The Morning |
| 31 |
Elegante | Little Star |
| 32 |
Four Preps | Big Man |
| 33 |
Tommy Edwards | It's All In The Game |
| 34 |
Paul Anka | Midnight |
| 35 |
Marino Marini Quartet | Volare (Nel Blu Dipinto Di Blu) |
| 36 |
Pat Boone | Sugar Moon |
| 37 |
Doris Day | Everybody Loves A Lover |
| 38 |
Olympics | Western Movies |
| 39 |
Lonnie Donegan | Lonesome Traveller |
| 40 |
Platters | Twilight Time |
